2. Tutorials
  3. hapi — How to Fix “handler method did not return a value, a promise, or throw an error”

hapi — How to Fix “handler method did not return a value, a promise, or throw an error”

The hapi v17 release comes with a paradigm shift from callbacks to async/await. This shift includes a learning curve for hapi developers, too. You’ll run into errors like handler method did not return a value, a promise, or throw an error.

What does this error mean and how to solve it?
Let’s make it clear in this tutorial.

hapi Series Overview

  1. Get Your Server Up and Running
  2. v17 Upgrade Guide (Your Move to async/await)
  3. Become a Better Developer in 2018
  4. Become a Better Developer in 2017
  1. What You’ll Build
  2. Prepare Your Project: Stack & Structure
  3. Environment Variables and Storing Secrets
  4. Set Up MongoDB and Connect With Mongoose
  5. Sending Emails in Node.js
  6. Load the User’s Profile Picture From Gravatar Using Virtuals in Mongoose
  7. Implement a User Profile Editing Screen
  8. Generate a Username in Mongoose Middleware
  9. Displaying Seasons and Episodes for TV Shows with Mongoose Relationship Population
  10. Implementing Pagination for Movies
  11. Implement a Watchlist
  12. Create a Full Text Search with MongoDB
  1. Create a REST API with JSON Endpoints
  2. Update Mongoose Models for JSON Responses
  3. API Pagination for TV Shows
  4. Customize API Endpoints with Query Parameters
  5. Always Throw and Handle API Validation Errors
  6. Advanced API Validation With Custom Errors
  7. Create an API Documentation with Swagger
  8. Customize Your Swagger API Documentation URL
  9. Describe Endpoint Details in Your Swagger API Documentation
  10. 10 Tips on API Testing With Postman
  11. JWT Authentication in Swagger API Documentation
  12. API Versioning with Request Headers
  1. IP-Based Rate Limits (Part 1 of 7)
  2. Rate Limits for Routes (Part 2 of 7)
  3. Dynamic Rate Limits (Part 3 of 7)
  4. Render a “Rate Limit Exceeded” View (Part 4 of 7)
  5. Show “Rate Limit Exceeded” Error on Login (Part 5 of 7)
  6. Disable Rate Limiting (Part 6 of 7)
  7. Rate Limiter Refactoring & Cleanup (Part 7 of 7)
  1. API Login With Username and Password to Generate a JWT
  2. JWT Authentication and Private API Endpoints
  3. Refresh Tokens With JWT Authentication
  4. Create a JWT Utility
  5. JWT Refresh Token for Multiple Devices
  6. Check Refresh Token in Authentication Strategy
  7. Rate Limit Your Refresh Token API Endpoint
  8. How to Revoke a JWT
  9. Invalidate JWTs With Blacklists
  10. JWT Logout (Part 1/2)
  11. JWT “Immediate” Logout (Part 2/2)
  12. A Better Place to Invalidate Tokens
  13. How to Switch the JWT Signing Algorithm
  14. Roll Your Own Refresh Token Authentication Scheme
  15. JWT Claims 101
  16. Use JWT With Asymmetric Signatures (RS256 & Co.)
  17. Encrypt the JWT Payload (The Simple Way)
  18. Increase JWT Security Beyond the Signature
  19. Unsigned JSON Web Tokens (Unsecured JWS)
  20. JWK and JWKS Overview
  21. Provide a JWKS API Endpoint
  22. Create a JWK from a Shared Secret
  23. JWT Verification via JWKS API Endpoint
  24. What is JOSE in JWT
  25. Encrypt a JWT (the JWE Way)
  26. Authenticate Encrypted JWTs (JWE)
  27. Encrypted and Signed JWT (Nested JWT)
  28. Bringing Back JWT Decoding and Authentication
  29. Bringing Back JWT Claims in the JWT Payload
  1. How to Run Separate Frontend and Backend Servers Within a Single Project
  2. How to Use Server Labels
  3. How to Correctly Stop Your Server and Close Existing Connections
  1. Basic Authentication With Username and Password
  2. Authentication and Remember Me Using Cookies
  3. How to Set a Default Authentication Strategy
  4. Define Multiple Authentication Strategies for a Route
  5. Restrict User Access With Scopes
  6. Show „Insufficient Scope“ View for Routes With Restricted Access
  7. Access Restriction With Dynamic and Advanced Scopes
  8. hapi - How to Fix „unknown authentication strategy“
  9. Authenticate with GitHub And Remember the Login
  10. Authenticate with GitLab And Remember the User
  11. How to Combine Bell With Another Authentication Strategy
  12. Custom OAuth Bell Strategy to Connect With any Server
  13. Redirect to Previous Page After Login
  14. How to Implement a Complete Sign Up Flow With Email and Password
  15. How to Implement a Complete Login Flow
  16. Implement a Password-Reset Flow
  1. Views in hapi 9 (and above)
  2. How to Render and Reply Views
  3. How to Reply and Render Pug Views (Using Pug 2.0)
  4. How to Create a Dynamic Handlebars Layout Template
  5. Create and Use Handlebars Partial Views
  6. Create and Use Custom Handlebars Helpers
  7. Specify a Different Handlebars Layout for a Specific View
  8. How to Create Jade-Like Layout Blocks in Handlebars
  9. Use Vue.js Mustache Tags in Handlebars Templates
  10. How to Use Multiple Handlebars Layouts
  1. Extend Your Server Functionality With Plugins
  2. Create Your Own Custom Plugin
  3. How to Register Plugins for a Selected Server Instance
  4. hapi Plugin for Client Geo Location (by Future Studio 🚀)
  5. Increase Development Speed With Errors in the Browser or as JSON Response
  1. Route Handling and Drive Traffic to Your Server
  2. How to Serve Static Files (Images, JS, CSS, etc.)
  3. How to Use Query Parameters
  4. Optional Path Parameters
  5. Multi-Segment/Wildcard Path Parameters
  6. Ignore Trailing Slashes on Route Paths
  7. How to Fix “Unsupported Media Type”
  1. How to Reply a JSON Response
  2. How to Set Response Status Code
  3. How to Handle 404 Responses for Missing Routes
  1. Query Parameter Validation With Joi
  2. Path Parameter Validation With Joi
  3. Request Payload Validation With Joi
  4. Validate Query and Path Parameters, Payload and Headers All at Once on Your Routes
  5. Validate Request Headers With Joi
  6. Reply Custom View for Failed Validations
  7. Handle Failed Validations and Show Errors Details at Inputs
  8. How to Fix AssertionError, Cannot validate HEAD or GET requests
  1. Add CSRF Protection on Forms and API Endpoints
  1. Report Errors to Sentry
  2. Don’t Report Errors to Sentry in Development Mode
  3. Logging Fundamentals
  4. Log to Console With Good
  5. Log to File With Good
  1. Getting Started With Testing Using Lab and Code
  2. Run Tests with Assertions using Code
  3. Test Route Handlers by Injecting Requests
  4. Inject Request Payload, Headers and Parameters While Testing Route Handlers
  1. Zero-Downtime Deployments Using PM2

What’s Causing the Problem?

The error message means that you returned undefined or null from your route handler. Hapi v17 expects you to return either a value, a promise or an error. Otherwise, the framework wouldn’t know what response to send.

Let’s look at the following sample code. It represents a route handler that searches for a tutorial based on a given slug. After the search, you return the tutorial right away.

'use strict'

handler: async (request, h) => {  
  const slug = request.params.slug
  const tutorial = await Tutorial.findBySlug(slug)

  // tutorial might be undefined
  // hapi wouldn’t know what "undefined" represents: success, error, server error?
  return tutorial
}

If the findBySlug() method on the Tutorial class does not throw an error, the value for tutorial would result in undefined.

The Solution: Always Return

Make sure to always return values, promises or errors from route handlers. That’s the way hapi knows how to respond the request.

The refactored code from above can have an extra check to send an error if there is no tutorial available for the given slug.

'use strict'

handler: async (request, h) => {  
  const slug = request.params.slug
  const tutorial = await Tutorial.findBySlug(slug)

  // explicitly return from route handlers: values, promises or errors

  if (!tutorial) {
    throw Boom.notFound(`No tutorial available for slug »${slug}«`)
  }

  return tutorial
}

The code snippet above shows two different responses: 404 Not Found response if there is no tutorial with the given slug or 200 OK if the slug matches a tutorial.

Summary

Watch out that all route handlers return values, either an actual value, an error or promises. Add checks in your code and respond with errors to situations where no “success” response is applicable.

Marcus Pöhls

Marcus is a fullstack JS developer. He’s passionate about the hapi framework for Node.js and loves to build web apps and APIs. Creator of Futureflix and the “learn hapi” learning path.

Explore the Library

Find interesting tutorials and solutions for your problems.

Android

Node.js

Server

Miscellaneous